1235 Bay St Staten Island Available For Sale

1235 Bay Street offers the kind of flexibility buyers and investors look for today. Located just off Hylan Boulevard in Rosebank, this 2,016 sq ft mixed-use building combines a renovated upstairs apartment with a ground-floor commercial storefront and a full basement. High visibility, strong traffic, and close proximity to major transit routes make this property a smart move for anyone seeking long-term value.

Property Highlights

Ground-Floor Commercial Space

The 1,000 sq ft retail storefront has been cleared and is ready for customization. Exposed brick walls, skylights, and tall ceilings bring character and light to the space. With direct sidewalk access and large windows, it’s ideal for a retail shop, café, office, or service-based business.

Full Basement

Beneath the storefront, a 900 sq ft basement offers substantial storage or operational capacity. High ceilings and an open layout make it suitable for inventory, equipment, or expansion needs.

Renovated Apartment

Upstairs, the one-bedroom, one-bathroom residential unit has been fully updated. Hardwood floors, crown molding, and multiple windows create a comfortable living space. A spacious living room flows into a formal dining area and den/office, providing both function and flexibility.

Kitchen & Dining

The kitchen features wood cabinetry, tiled flooring, and modern appliances, while the dining area can easily host gatherings. Together, they form a practical layout for daily living.

Bedroom Retreat

The bedroom offers a quiet retreat with natural light and ample space for full furnishings.

Outdoor Potential

The property also includes an unfinished backyard — a flexible area that could serve as tenant outdoor space, private use, or future commercial seating.

Location & Neighborhood

Rosebank is known for its accessibility and character. From 1235 Bay Street, you’re minutes to the Staten Island Ferry, Verrazzano Bridge, and express bus routes into Manhattan and Brooklyn. The property sits along a stretch of Bay Street lined with restaurants, shops, and services, while nearby waterfront views and local parks add to the appeal.

Investment & Lifestyle Potential

This property offers multiple pathways for value. Lease the storefront to generate commercial rent while securing consistent income from the apartment. Or, for an owner-operator, live upstairs while running your business at street level. The full basement provides storage rarely found in mixed-use properties, further boosting its appeal.

With R4A zoning, strong visibility, and proximity to Staten Island’s North Shore redevelopment corridor, 1235 Bay Street is positioned to perform well both now and into the future.