Tucked away in a quiet residential pocket of Sayreville, New Jersey, 43 Pershing Avenue presents a rare mix of opportunity and livability that’s hard to match in today’s market. Spanning over an acre and already subdivided into three buildable lots, this is not just a home—it’s a blank canvas for multigenerational living, smart development, or long-term investment.
Whether you’re a builder looking for your next project, a homeowner dreaming of a private compound, or an investor seeking a property with multiple exit strategies, this offering checks all the boxes.
Link to Listing → 43 Pershing Ave, Sayreville NJ 08872
A Private Setting With a Flexible Future
What makes 43 Pershing Ave truly special is its location and layout. While technically a single address, the 47,088 square-foot lot has already been subdivided into three parcels, saving future owners time, money, and red tape. That opens the door to a range of possibilities:
- Build two new homes while keeping the existing residence
- Sell off one or two lots and reduce your cost basis
- Create a secluded multigenerational estate
- Develop rental units or high-end custom homes
All of this, while enjoying a quiet, tucked-away position just off Bailey Place, a lesser-traveled road that enhances privacy without compromising access to local amenities.
A Custom-Built Raised Ranch with Substance
Set back from the street and wrapped in full brick, the existing home on Lot 1 is a custom-designed raised ranch that stretches nearly 4,000 square feet across two levels. It was built with a clear vision: comfort, flow, and room to grow.
Inside, you’re welcomed by a large courtyard-style entry, a rare architectural detail that softens the transition between indoors and outdoors. Once inside, you’ll notice that the spaces feel open but not overwhelming. The footprint is generous, but the layout is practical.
Main Level Highlights:
- Eat-in kitchen with room for a full-size table and plenty of prep space
- Formal living and dining rooms positioned for easy hosting
- Den with wood-burning fireplace for relaxed evenings
- Laundry room and powder room set privately off the main living area
- Primary suite with its own ¾ bath—recently redone
- Two additional bedrooms sharing a second ¾ bath
Everything on the main floor flows without clutter, and the oversized windows draw in light from all angles—without relying on cliché phrases like “abundant natural light,” let’s just say it feels bright and balanced without being overexposed.
A Lower Level That Lives Like Its Own Apartment
Unlike many raised ranch homes that relegate the lower level to basic storage or rec space, here it’s fully finished and highly functional. There’s a second kitchen, ¾ bath, and two additional bonus rooms that could serve as bedrooms, office space, or an in-law suite setup.
Direct walkout access to a rear patio means the lower level lives almost like a separate apartment—ideal for guests, live-in relatives, or future rental income.
Expansion-Ready Attic + Oversized Garage
The home was designed with future expansion in mind. A full walk-up attic sits above the main living space—unfinished but easily accessible and filled with potential. Want a new primary suite? A rec room? A studio or gym? It’s your call.
The attached two-car garage and long, oversized driveway can easily accommodate multiple vehicles, trailers, or recreational equipment.
Room to Build Without Leaving Home
Even if you never plan to sell or build on the two additional lots, just knowing the option is there adds value and flexibility.
Imagine:
- Keeping the land for future generations
- Selling one lot now to lower your effective purchase price
- Partnering with a builder to develop custom homes on the additional parcels
- Using the extra land for gardens, workshops, or recreational space
That kind of freedom is increasingly rare in suburban settings.
Location: Quiet Yet Convenient
Sayreville is one of Central New Jersey’s best-kept secrets for buyers who want space, access, and value. You’re just minutes from:
- Route 9, Garden State Parkway, and NJ Turnpike
- Local shopping centers, parks, and schools
- The South Amboy train station and waterfront
- Easy commutes to Staten Island, Brooklyn, or New Brunswick
Whether you work nearby or just want a break from the congestion of city life, this location makes daily routines feel less stressful.
Investment Angles
From an investment standpoint, this property hits several strong marks:
- Subdivided lots are ready for construction—no waiting for township approvals
- Multiple configurations are possible: hold, build, rent, or sell
- No HOA restrictions mean you can design freely (within local zoning)
And with the inventory crunch continuing across New Jersey, especially for new construction, land like this becomes more valuable each year.
Why This Property Is Different
So many listings today blur together with similar photos, the same language, and vague claims of potential. This one stands out because it’s built on something real:
- Real square footage
- Real development potential
- Real thought in the design
- And a real opportunity to create something personal, lasting, and profitable
Interested?
This kind of property doesn’t come around often—especially with three subdivided lots already in place.
To learn more or schedule a private showing, contact:
Anthony Volpe
📞 718-200-7799
📧 info@prereal.com
🌐 PreReal™ Prendamano Real Estate
Leave a Comment