A 3-Story Eltingville Home with Space Most Townhomes Don’t Have

It’s not often you see a semi-attached home sitting on a 9,176 square foot lot in Eltingville. That’s what makes 21 Pompey Avenue stand out right away.

With 2,112 square feet of interior space, four bedrooms, 2.5 baths, and a separate private first-level layout, this home offers flexibility that’s hard to find in this price range.

Property Overview

• 4 Bedrooms
• 2.5 Bathrooms
• 3 Stories
• 2,112 Sq Ft Interior
• 9,176 Sq Ft Lot
• Annual Taxes: $8,130
• Private First-Level Living Area with Separate Entrance
• Deck + Yard Access
• Central Air | Forced Air | Natural Gas

Long Sightlines. Easy Furniture Placement.

The main level stretches long and open. The living and dining area flow together, giving you enough space for a full dining setup and a comfortable seating area without feeling tight. Large front windows pull in natural light across the entire room.

The staircase runs along the side wall, adding architectural structure while keeping the layout open.

A Kitchen That Faces the Conversation

The kitchen offers a wide working layout with light wood cabinetry, generous counter space, and a peninsula that opens toward the family room. It’s practical. It works. And it connects directly to the heart of the home.

Behind it, the den features a brick fireplace and sliding door access to the deck. This space feels separate enough for movie nights, but still connected to the kitchen for everyday convenience.

Bedrooms That Don’t Feel Like Afterthoughts

Upstairs, three bedrooms offer comfortable layouts with closet space and good light. The primary bedroom includes mirrored closet doors that reflect light and visually expand the room.

Each bedroom feels personal but functional — easy to repaint, redesign, or keep as is.

Separate. Private. Valuable.

This is where the layout gets interesting.

The first level includes a one-bedroom, one-bath configuration with its own entrance. That opens possibilities:

• Guest suite
• Extended family setup
• Home office with privacy
• Potential rental arrangement (verify local guidelines)

It’s not just “extra space.” It’s a separate space.

Clean Lines. Simple Finishes.

The full baths are clean and functional, with strong lighting and simple finishes. One features a skylight that brings in overhead daylight — something buyers always notice.

Space Beyond the Walls

A 9,176 square foot lot is significant for this property type.

You get a raised deck off the main level for grilling or outdoor dining. Below, there’s real yard depth — space for play, pets, or future landscaping upgrades.

The front paver driveway adds strong curb appeal and offers ample parking in addition to garage space.

South Shore Convenience Without the Noise

21 Pompey Avenue sits in the heart of Eltingville, one of Staten Island’s most convenient South Shore neighborhoods.

You’re close to:

• Eltingville Transit Center (bus + train access)
• Hylan Boulevard shopping corridor
• Local supermarkets and daily essentials
• Restaurants and neighborhood services
• Parks and South Shore waterfront areas

You can commute when you need to. But you don’t feel stuck in congestion.

Layout That Protects Value

For buyers thinking long-term, this layout offers options.

The separate lower-level setup increases flexibility and resale value. The oversized lot offers expansion or outdoor improvement potential. And the 4-bedroom configuration keeps the home competitive in the Eltingville market.

Annual taxes at $8,130 also remain reasonable for the square footage and lot size.

This is the kind of property that grows with you.

Final Thoughts

If you’ve been looking in Eltingville and feel like most homes blend together — this one doesn’t.

The lot size stands out.
The layout adds flexibility.
The location checks the practical boxes.

Now it’s just about seeing it in person.

See the Space in Person

Schedule a Private Showing

For more information or to book a private tour:Shana Conroy
📞 718-200-7799
📧 info@www.prereal.com
🌐 PreReal™ Prendamano Real Estate